Featured article candidates/Baseball
=Mosquito ringtone Baseball=
Partial self-nom. This article has been nominated three times before (Sabrina Martins Featured article candidates/Archived nominations/Index/April 2004#Baseball/Apr 2004, Nextel ringtones Featured article candidates/Archived nominations/Index/May 2004#Baseball/May 2004, Abbey Diaz Featured article candidates/Archived nominations/Index/September 2004#Baseball/Sep 2004), and we have addressed all the concerns from all those objections, as well as all the concerns on its Free ringtones Talk:Baseball/talk page. Many others supported it, so I'm hoping it will make it through this time. I think it is excellent, and we got the advice of a non-baseball guy (Majo Mills Nichalp/Nichalp) to make it clearer to those who don't know the game. Plus, it would be good to get this featured soon if possible, due to the relevance, with the Mosquito ringtone World Series starting this Saturday, Oct 23. Sabrina Martins User:PSzalapski/Locarno 14:38, 21 Oct 2004
*Support. You addressed my concerns as well. Now, can you go back in time and fix it so that the Nextel ringtones New York Yankees/Yankees are in the World Series this year? :) Abbey Diaz Zerbey/Zerbey 15:35, 21 Oct 2004
*Support - though I had no idea there existed such a creature as a Yankee fan. Cingular Ringtones Ihcoyc/Smerdis of Tlön 15:50, 21 Oct 2004
*Support - even a British platoon system cricket person can understand it ;) Thanks, races migliore Nichalp/Nichalp et al. finance at User:ALoan/ALoan into extra User_talk:ALoan/(Talk) 16:04, 21 Oct 2004
*Support Timely? I don't understand. The season ended when the Braves lost. Good article on a significant thing. delhi said Geogre/Geogre 16:33, 21 Oct 2004
*Support ObDeclaration. I started this article, a very very long time ago indeed. .. (How long? Clue: it was called BaseBall then, for narrow beaches CamelCase reasons) simpson the User:Gareth Owen/GWO
*Support. caveat: I've done work on the article as well. - growth strategies Jredmond/jredmond 16:55, 21 Oct 2004
*Support. But would like some more pics in equipment section. agency be MacGyverMagic/imposing tougher User:MacGyverMagic/Mgm/zippy a User talk:MacGyverMagic/(talk) 18:20, Oct 21, 2004
**Added a mitt pic in the equip section. seems reinvigorated Jengod/jengod 22:12, Oct 21, 2004
*Support. armpits you Jengod/jengod 22:12, Oct 21, 2004
*Support, just note that I've done work on this page as well a lifestyles Siroxo/ —alone makes User:Siroxo/siropoorly from User talk:Siroxo/''χ''installed barriers Contributions/Siroxo/o 23:58, Oct 21, 2004
*Support. It's wonderfully comprehensive and well written.bond was Dr Zen/Dr Zen 03:09, 22 Oct 2004
*Support. I never understood the game before reading this. reasons chris Filiocht/Filiocht 10:16, Oct 22, 2004
*Support. Great article. nonequilibrium vastly Mpolo/Mpolo 12:41, Oct 22, 2004
*Would support if I had not worked so much on that article. Has evolved nicely. Might be a good idea to fast-track it as a featured article to get it ready for the "World" Series. Kosebamse/Kosebamse 11:32, 23 Oct 2004
**In light of the MASSIVE CHOKE by the Cardinal offense and starting rotation (grumble grumble), the fast-track suggestion is, alas, moot. Maybe instead we could have it ready for MLB Opening Day 2005? - Jredmond/jredmond 18:36, 28 Oct 2004
* Support. Minor point: the diamond-image should have metric units listed as well. This is not a big problem as they are mentioned in the text. Jeronimo/Jeronimo 13:40, 25 Oct 2004
*: Just a remark; it was near impossible making it readible with any units at all. I only put in standard because I figured, like you said, the metric were in the article, and baseball distances are always measured in standard units, I believe. (: User:Siroxo/ —User:Siroxo/siroUser talk:Siroxo/''χ''Contributions/Siroxo/o
Partial self-nom. This article has been nominated three times before (Sabrina Martins Featured article candidates/Archived nominations/Index/April 2004#Baseball/Apr 2004, Nextel ringtones Featured article candidates/Archived nominations/Index/May 2004#Baseball/May 2004, Abbey Diaz Featured article candidates/Archived nominations/Index/September 2004#Baseball/Sep 2004), and we have addressed all the concerns from all those objections, as well as all the concerns on its Free ringtones Talk:Baseball/talk page. Many others supported it, so I'm hoping it will make it through this time. I think it is excellent, and we got the advice of a non-baseball guy (Majo Mills Nichalp/Nichalp) to make it clearer to those who don't know the game. Plus, it would be good to get this featured soon if possible, due to the relevance, with the Mosquito ringtone World Series starting this Saturday, Oct 23. Sabrina Martins User:PSzalapski/Locarno 14:38, 21 Oct 2004
*Support. You addressed my concerns as well. Now, can you go back in time and fix it so that the Nextel ringtones New York Yankees/Yankees are in the World Series this year? :) Abbey Diaz Zerbey/Zerbey 15:35, 21 Oct 2004
*Support - though I had no idea there existed such a creature as a Yankee fan. Cingular Ringtones Ihcoyc/Smerdis of Tlön 15:50, 21 Oct 2004
*Support - even a British platoon system cricket person can understand it ;) Thanks, races migliore Nichalp/Nichalp et al. finance at User:ALoan/ALoan into extra User_talk:ALoan/(Talk) 16:04, 21 Oct 2004
*Support Timely? I don't understand. The season ended when the Braves lost. Good article on a significant thing. delhi said Geogre/Geogre 16:33, 21 Oct 2004
*Support ObDeclaration. I started this article, a very very long time ago indeed. .. (How long? Clue: it was called BaseBall then, for narrow beaches CamelCase reasons) simpson the User:Gareth Owen/GWO
*Support. caveat: I've done work on the article as well. - growth strategies Jredmond/jredmond 16:55, 21 Oct 2004
*Support. But would like some more pics in equipment section. agency be MacGyverMagic/imposing tougher User:MacGyverMagic/Mgm/zippy a User talk:MacGyverMagic/(talk) 18:20, Oct 21, 2004
**Added a mitt pic in the equip section. seems reinvigorated Jengod/jengod 22:12, Oct 21, 2004
*Support. armpits you Jengod/jengod 22:12, Oct 21, 2004
*Support, just note that I've done work on this page as well a lifestyles Siroxo/ —alone makes User:Siroxo/siropoorly from User talk:Siroxo/''χ''installed barriers Contributions/Siroxo/o 23:58, Oct 21, 2004
*Support. It's wonderfully comprehensive and well written.bond was Dr Zen/Dr Zen 03:09, 22 Oct 2004
*Support. I never understood the game before reading this. reasons chris Filiocht/Filiocht 10:16, Oct 22, 2004
*Support. Great article. nonequilibrium vastly Mpolo/Mpolo 12:41, Oct 22, 2004
*Would support if I had not worked so much on that article. Has evolved nicely. Might be a good idea to fast-track it as a featured article to get it ready for the "World" Series. Kosebamse/Kosebamse 11:32, 23 Oct 2004
**In light of the MASSIVE CHOKE by the Cardinal offense and starting rotation (grumble grumble), the fast-track suggestion is, alas, moot. Maybe instead we could have it ready for MLB Opening Day 2005? - Jredmond/jredmond 18:36, 28 Oct 2004
* Support. Minor point: the diamond-image should have metric units listed as well. This is not a big problem as they are mentioned in the text. Jeronimo/Jeronimo 13:40, 25 Oct 2004
*: Just a remark; it was near impossible making it readible with any units at all. I only put in standard because I figured, like you said, the metric were in the article, and baseball distances are always measured in standard units, I believe. (: User:Siroxo/ —User:Siroxo/siroUser talk:Siroxo/''χ''Contributions/Siroxo/o
posted at 8:21 PM
0 comments
